Skating Federation Had Initially Decide to Have a New Panel of Judges
Watch Video of Skating Pairs and Re-Score the Russians, Canadians;
French Judge Begged ISU to 'Get Me Out of This,' Source Says
Sale, Pelletier Received Half Dozen Heavily Accented Phone Messages
After Winning World Championship Saying They had not 'Deserved to Win,'
And 'Were Not Going to Win at the Olympics,'
NEW YORK, Feb. 17 /PRNewswire/ -- In response to the controversy that
erupted last week over the pairs skating competition in which the Russians
were awarded the gold medal over the flawless skating performance of the
Canadians, Newsweek has learned that the skating federation had originally
decided to have two new panels of judges watch video of the pairs skate, on
Thursday morning, and re-score it. But officials quickly realized that denying
Russian pair Elena Berezhnaya and Anton Sikharulidze their gold medal would
stir up yet another hornet's nest. So instead they hauled in French judge
Marie Reine Le Gougne Thursday afternoon and questioned her about whether she
was pressured to vote for the Russians. An official close to the International
Olympic Committee says she confessed to playing some sort of role in the
fiasco, broke down weeping and fell to her knees, begging the International
Skating Union to "get me out of this," reports Senior Editor Sharon Begley in
the February 25 issue of Newsweek (on newsstands Monday, February 18).
(Photo: http://www.newscom.com/cgi-bin/prnh/20020217/HSSU003 )
By that time, the ISU had several affidavits describing how Le Gougne had
traded her first-place vote for Elena and Anton in exchange for a first-place
vote from the Russian judge for the French ice-dancing pair in the next
competition. Having heard Le Gougne's confession on Friday morning, ISU
President Ottavio Cinquanta heard Le Gougne's confession and officially
proposed to the IOC that Canadians Jamie Sale and David Pelletier be awarded
the gold medal as well.
Newsweek has also learned that there had been hints of a conspiracy
against Sale and Pelletier months before the Olympics. When Jamie and David
got back to their room after winning the World Skating Championships last
March, they had half a dozen heavily accented phone messages, says a source
close to Canadian skating. The messages said the pair had not "deserved to
win," and "were not going to win at the Olympics."
However, rather than burying the fiasco, the quick resolution to the
controversy reinforced the view that figure skating has a lot to hide -- so
much, in fact, that the ISU would take the unprecedented step of agreeing to a
double gold in order to avoid too much digging into suspect judging. The
scandal had already opened up a window into the longstanding practice of
figure-skating judges cutting backroom deals, trading votes and prejudging
competitions. "I'm glad this is happening," says longtime skating judge Bonnie
McLauthlin. "It's been going on forever." Worse, it blackened the reputation
of the entire Olympics. "It's an ugly little dark secret that there are deals
made [in figure skating]," said David D'Allessandro, chairman and CEO of
financial services giant (and Olympics sponsor) John Hancock. "In the past it
might have been left to float along within the [skating] federation. But now
the image of the Olympics is at stake."
The controversy did more than cast a pall over the Games and its marquee
sport. Unlike previous figure skating dust-ups, this one threatened to make
world-class meets seem as fixed as a wrestling match between Triple X and The
Rock. Skating and Olympics officials have long turned a blind eye to all this.
"Our sport has gangrene," recently-retired ice dancer Sophie Moniotte of
France tells Newsweek. "In most sports doping is the problem. With figure
skating it's deals and manipulation."
And ice dancing is a prime example. Suffice it to say that longtime judges
recall that the final rankings would often be determined "at a cocktail party
[of the figure skating association], and nothing short of withdrawal of a
couple from competition would ever change that order for the year," ex-judge
Nancy Nelson tells Newsweek. But Skategate may do what previous judging
scandals have failed to do, Begley writes: force much-needed reforms in figure
skating.
(Read Newsweek's news releases at
http://www.Newsweek.MSNBC.com. Click "Pressroom.")
Click Here For Special Offer
SOURCE Newsweek
back to top
Related links: http://www.newsweek.msnbc.com
Photo Notes: NewsCom: http://www.newscom.com/cgi-bin/prnh/20020217/HSSU003 AP PhotoExpress Network: PRN1 PRN Photo Desk, 888-776-6555 or 212-782-2840
CONTACT: Rosanna Maietta of Newsweek, +1-212-445-4859
|